Chapter Text
The sun baking New Bedford was invisible belowdecks, but its presence was inescapable.
There was a fan blowing, circulating air, but it still smelled like brine, marine life (and death), diesel fuel, oil, metal and work, and while Scotty wished he could cool off down there, and while he occasionally gave a passing thought to how many braincells he was killing by breathing in those fumes, he was getting paid a princely sum for the discomfort, on top of the already kingly sum he had hidden in a lockbox in his rented house.
Jumping off the pier into the oil-sheen rainbow on the polluted water around the fishing fleet to cool off would just be risking sickness anyway; the afternoon sun had no mercy, but if he really did want to swim, it wasn’t terribly far to safe beaches.
It was still definitely better than New York had been, anyway, where he had spent a worrying amount of time feeling like someone had rubbed a cheese grater against the lining of his lungs, no thanks to the smog, and where crime and poverty and despair were only a little less endemic than the rats. And at least in New Bedford, choosing to continue existing for one more day was easier.
Not always easy. But-- easier.
There was a clang somewhere half above, half to the side of him and then a voice called out, "Hey, Scotty! Someone's on the phone for ya!"
He had a home phone, so very few people would have thought to call him at work. And only one person from his own time even knew where he worked, which narrowed down the list considerably.
That was ultimately enough for him to set his spanner down and climb back out of the guts of the trawler, wincing sharply as the sun hit him. "Did they say what they wanted, lad?" he asked, carefully pulling his sunglasses out of his hair to put them on, minding not to touch the lenses, and breathing a sigh of relief when the light went from searing to somewhat less of an assault.
Terry shrugged, offering over an old t-shirt that had been ripped into a rag. "They said that you won the Publisher's Clearing House sweepstakes and you should get on the phone right away."
Scotty took the rag even as he rolled his eyes heavenwards, and gave the kid's head a gentle push on the way past, making sure to transfer just a little of the grease in the process.
Turning a spanner in the twentieth century wasn't all that different from turning one in the twenty-third; everything had become more refined, more efficient, safer, cleaner, and more environmentally friendly in the future, but the principles were the same and so were the skills needed. He was every bit as much of a mechanic as he was an engineer, and even in the twenty-third century, he had worked on commercial boat engines, both as a lad of fifteen through eighteen, and then as a moonlighting job while out on disability. Or later, just as a hobby during the Enterprise’s refits. He knew how to fabricate parts in a machine shop after backwards engineering them, or even redesigning them altogether; he could weld, too. And he could lead and teach, if it came to it.
Of the five of them, Scotty was -- by quite a number of kilometers -- the best suited to build a good, comfortable life very quickly in this era.
It was just a wee bit ironic that he was also the one least interested in continuing to live one, too.
But once he'd landed here, in the deeply competitive commercial fishing port of New Bedford, it had taken him no time to make a name for himself. He just followed the sound of cursing, clanging and desperation, freelanced for a week and a half -- earning enough to feed and lodge himself and a bit more besides -- and by then, everyone knew his name.
And everyone wanted to hire him.
There had been an out and out bidding war between vessel owners for his permanent employment -- not only for their sake, but to deny him to the competition -- and so Scotty had spent some time letting the offers come in, and all the while he pressed a smile for people that he didn't quite feel, shook a hell of a lot of hands, got mistaken for Canadian plenty of times, ached into his soul for the Massachusetts accents surrounding him -- not so far different from the Maine accent -- and eventually found himself sleeping in Dan Howland's guest room.
Howland had given him the best offer -- not the highest, but the most well-rounded, an hourly wage plus a percentage per catch for every vessel Howland owned -- and threw in the use of his pickup truck until Scotty could get his own car or truck. And even if his wasn’t the highest offer, it was still a hell of a lot higher than Scotty had made working at the garage in New York.
More, for that matter, than all five of them had been able to bring in combined. Twice over.
He'd come here in January and by the end of the month, he had a job, a place to rest his head and a vehicle to use. By the time winter turned to spring, he had enough to rent a nice little place in Fairhaven, which was helped along by Howland's connections, deep and many.
By June, Scotty had a fine -- if maybe impractical -- car and had bought that old pickup off of Howland, too, for when he wanted something more utilitarian than a '72 Stingray. Then he put to sea for almost two months, while Howland's fleet tried to race the inevitability of a struggling fishery, transferring from vessel to vessel without even coming in to port, occasionally throwing his hand in on setting out and hauling in, at least when he wasn't taking his turn at the helm or keeping the engines and ice makers running.
(It had been about the hardest physical labor he'd ever performed, and that was taking into account that Scotty already worked, even in his own time. He had all of a week to get past the seasickness, regain his sealegs and rest up, and then he barely had time to stop, sleep, eat or anything else, he was so busy. But he also made a very handsome five figures for it, and hadn't once thought of dying while out there.)
He was still a little unsteady on land as yet, used to the constant motion of the sea; even as he headed into the office, he was trying to compensate for a rolling deck he wasn’t on and ignoring the way it made his bad hip twinge. But he made it, picked up the phone with the rag and asked, "Hello?"
"Scotty," was the slightly rushed, southern accented reply. "Thank heavens. Can you come down to the city?"
McCoy. One of Scotty’s eyebrows climbed a fraction, but he didn’t hang up. "Why would I do that? I've got work, McCoy, I've been breakin' my back from before sunup, so whatever it is had better be more important than that."
He didn't know what kind of reply he expected, but it wasn’t the one he got. "It's Spock," McCoy said, seriously. "He's sick and gettin' sicker, and I figured you'd better know."
All right, that was definitely more important.
Scotty glanced out at the boat he'd been working on, did some calculations, made a plan or three and then answered, "I'll be down tonight."
Spock was, without any doubt, the only reason Scotty wasn't some well-picked skeleton dug into the seabed in the Gulf of Maine right now.
Dan hadn’t been thrilled with Scotty telling him he was going before the end of the work day, but while the man was hard and not a little mercenary in business, he was also fair and honest. The fleet was in good shape, absent the usual overhaul of tired parts and routine maintenance, and Scotty figured that they'd manage without him for a couple of days.
He lit out of Fairhaven in the pickup -- hell if he was gonna take a Corvette into the city to land in a chop shop -- and with enough clothing and cash to see him through the next couple to few days (and more yet to give to Spock), getting on I-95 southbound, at first driving into the sun then finally putting it over his right shoulder. He liked his odds of missing even the tail-end of rush hour, but he still drove with worry gnawing in his gut.
Out of all of them, he had only known James Kirk and Nyota Uhura for two years, and Leonard McCoy for one. By comparison, he and Spock had met sixteen years before that and had spent almost all of that time as shipmates. The only times they weren't were during refits and when Spock was on special assignment elsewhere.
And while they were both deeply private individuals, and had never really chosen to share that private space before, that much time could not pass without parts of their lives being braided together regardless.
Spock was the only one left aboard the Enterprise who had met Scotty’s adopted brother. Scotty was the only one left aboard the Enterprise who knew of Spock's adopted sister; who knew the name of Michael Burnham and who had seen the aftermath of what losing her had done to Spock. They both had been -- would always be -- fiercely loyal to Chris Pike, and Pike had asked both of them to stay on for Kirk when they had otherwise been considering other paths.
They shared music sometimes. Fought alongside one another. Bled together, for that matter. Tried to help Pike together. They never became friends, but they were something more than colleagues, too.
So, it was Spock who had followed Scotty out into the cruel December night some months back. And despite how painful the Vulcan had to find it, the below-freezing temperatures, he had merely fallen into step. He didn’t try to convince Scotty to go back, just kept pace.
Then again, Spock had also been hard done by. The whole situation was ugly in so many ways that there could be no winners, aside maybe Jim Kirk and Edith Keeler. Even though McCoy and Uhura both had acquiesced to Kirk, Scotty couldn’t imagine their lives here would be easy.
But it so turned out that neither he, nor Spock, could do the deed themselves despite discussing it. Edith Keeler needed to die, their entire future depended on it, but by the time they were able to recreate duotronics and access the tricorder, the time had passed when she was supposed to.
And then, in another historical record, she was supposed to die towards the end of December instead, burned straight through with what could only be a phaser. And Kirk had decided then and there that he couldn’t let that happen or do it himself. And he declared that he would protect her life with his own and with lethal force. And he had put it to them to decide whether to stay or not, as if they had anything of a choice in the matter.
Spock and Scotty had both refused to give into that farce. And even though it got them suspicious looks from Kirk and McCoy -- Nyota was a class-act regardless, clearly empathizing even as she had her own choices to live with, given she had bonded with Edith herself -- the two of them had gone outside and tried to figure out what they could do.
No one wanted the woman dead. Edith was-- sweet. Generous and driven by compassion. A bit of a zealot, but her heart was good. Scotty thought it was a damn bad idea for Kirk to get involved with her when they needed to be getting home, but he had no trouble seeing how the captain had done so. He’d not been much younger himself when he’d gotten involved with Fio Langley, despite regulations, so he knew that the heart didn’t always pause for common sense.
Admittedly, it would have only been their careers if he and Fio had been caught. Not the entire damned future. But-- none of them had known that then. So, aside from wishing Kirk would focus more on getting them home and less on his lady love, Scotty didn’t figure it would be that bad. Not unless Kirk got her pregnant, anyway.
And so, when it still looked like they would get to go home, Scotty had endured being stuck in far too small a space with far too many people, clinging with both hands to the idea that they were working towards that goal. But when the weather was even barely warm enough and he wasn’t working or trying to reinvent technology with Spock, he spent a hell of a lot of time outside. He wouldn’t have been able to stay sane in that pressure cooker if he hadn’t had an escape option.
He might’ve picked up overtime, but working without papers meant that the garage he was working out of wouldn’t have to pay it, so instead he spent that time walking or riding the bus (even he wasn’t desperate enough to chance the subway), sometimes not bothering to come back for a night or two, relying mostly on his wits and prior experience to get him through it.
(Beyond his mechanical aptitude giving him an important advantage, he was reasonably sure he was the only one of them who’d ever dozed under a bridge or in a doorway. Or woven expertly through a commercial kitchen, with the easy grace of practice, to steal some dinner before anyone noticed he wasn’t supposed to be there.
Scotty had no qualms about exercising those very, very old skills, nor with playing the lost Scottish tourist in Manhattan long enough for someone in business clothes to pity him and pay his cab fare for somewhere else. He didn’t thieve from individuals, he certainly didn’t hurt anyone, but he was an old hand at surviving. This city was mean in many ways, far meaner than any in the future, and there were a few times he felt he was maybe taking too many risks with his own life, but given the choice between that and being crammed into that apartment, it was an easy choice to keep taking them.)
So, he’d endured and did his part to keep them sheltered, fed and clothed; he and Spock eventually managed to arrange identification for them all -- not strictly legally -- and then right after that they’d reinvented duotronics, and then--
Spock had walked with him to the garage he’d been working at on that Friday night in December; it was from there that Scotty intended to steal the yellow Mustang that his boss stored for the winter in one of the bays and leave the city.
Leave a few other things, too.
Scotty was angry and bitter and his hand was throbbing from where he’d punched Kirk twice in the mouth, breaking a finger but also claiming at least half a tooth and maybe more, and since he couldn’t make himself kill a kind woman who had been condemned by history, not even to save his future, not even to save his family, he had no intentions of sticking around any longer.
The plan was simple: Take the Mustang. The garage was closed for the long weekend and through Christmas, too, so that car wasn’t gonna be missed until Tuesday, and by then, it wasn’t gonna matter.
Find a good station on the radio and crank it up. Put the pedal to the floor, head north.
What seas what shores what gray rocks and what islands--
Go home in the only way that he had left.
“The traditional farewell of Vulcan wouldn’t be appropriate here,” Spock had said, quietly, speaking for the first time since they had left that miserable apartment. Bundled up in a heavy coat that Edith had gotten for him, he still looked threadbare in the artificial lights of the city. “To wish you peace and long life. But I regret I couldn’t give that to you; either the farewell or the fact of it.”
By now, the incandescent fury that had Scotty landing on Kirk and rearranging some teeth had burned down to a sorry flicker and a grief so deep that there was no fathoming the bottom of it. So long as he’d thought he’d be able to go home, he could have faced anything, he was sure; could have survived here or anywhere else while chasing that hope. And if not, if he would have died chasing it, then he would have at least had the belief that the people he loved would be able to continue without him.
Now, they were ghosts of some nonexistent future. And here he was, still alive.
He dragged a shuddering breath in through his teeth. For Spock’s words; the kindness of them. And the sorrow in them.
They’d been living pressed back-to-back and shoulder to shoulder almost literally since landing here; had worked diligently, and desperately, trying to find their way back to where they were supposed to be. To find what needed repaired so that they might repair it; to write all they had lived and loved and fought for back into existence.
And they had failed. Because they couldn’t make themselves into something they weren’t, they had failed.
“I’m sorry that I couldn’t return it to ye,” Scotty said, once he was sure he could do so without his voice breaking on him.
Spock hummed quietly, then asked, “You have a taste for Eliot, correct?”
The sideways nature of the question had caught Scotty off guard -- and mercifully enough paused the ache in his throat and behind his eyes -- and he’d looked over, eyebrows furrowed. “Aye.” Spock knew that; he’d admired the hand-bound book of T. S. Eliot’s poetry that Scotty had been given for his fortieth birthday, having stopped by his office and having spotted it there.
But there must have been some further purpose to the question. With Spock, there always was.
“A gift from your brother,” Spock agreed, clearly meaning the love of the poetry and not the physical book, though both were gifts from the same man; he didn’t look over himself, but went on to quote:
“Where is the end of them, the fishermen sailing
“Into the wind's tail, where the fog cowers?
“We cannot think of a time that is oceanless
“Or of an ocean not littered with wastage
“Or of a future that is not liable
“Like the past, to have no destination.
“We have to think of them as forever bailing,
“Setting and hauling, while the North East lowers
“Over shallow banks unchanging and erosionless
“Or drawing their money, drying sails at dockage;
“Not as making a trip that will be unpayable
“For a haul that will not bear examination.
“I hope you’ll forgive me if I choose to keep your memory in such a fashion,” Spock added, then turned towards him and offered his hand. “Forever bailing, setting and hauling, while the North East lowers over shallow banks, unchanged.”
It wasn’t strictly happy -- the Four Quartets were, in general, deeply introspective stuff -- but the thought of at least one person picturing him as somewhere alive and as being unwilling to entertain the truth was more than Scotty would have ever asked for, and the words resonated even down into that bottomless well of grief.
He reached out and took Spock’s hand; not quite a shake. The dry heat of Vulcan reflected between their hands, in the press of skin. “It was an honor, Mister Spock,” Scotty said, lifting his chin a little.
Spock had held on briefly harder; barely, a subtle gesture, but clear as bell nonetheless. “Goodbye, Mister Scott.”
He didn’t look back as he walked away.
Scotty had stood there for-- he couldn’t have guessed how long after. Still, but for the tears, and those only a bare fraction of the grief. But he didn’t go into the garage to get that Mustang, as the night spun past; for whatever reason, he kept coming back to the realization that once he was gone, Spock would be alone. If not necessarily literally, then still in a real and profound way. And that Scotty had some small chance to do something about it.
Eventually, as the first gray light started to crack the darkness of night, he had mopped his face off on his cuff, made the first of many repeating choices to live through the day, and then turned and walked in the opposite direction than Spock had gone in.
He was on a Greyhound northbound by afternoon with nothing but two twenties and some change in his pocket, the clothes on his back and no great desire to be alive, but with a choice to remain so for now anyway. And he worked the first few weeks of a new year with a splinted finger.
Scotty hadn’t gone back to the city since. But once he’d landed somewhere stable, he’d called the apartment and was incredibly grateful Nyota had answered the phone; he gave Spock the number to Howland’s house and had found himself smiling, halfway, for how the Vulcan seemed absolutely unsurprised to hear he was alive.
It was the first smile Scotty had actually felt since-- probably sometime around October, maybe? And he didn’t take that for granted.
“Anyway, go to the local Western Union office to ye, I’ve sent ye somethin’ to get by on,” Scotty had said, because he knew how hard Spock found even eating in this time to be, especially in the dead of winter, especially in a food desert like he’d been stuck in. “And I’ll call again in a week, 'bout the same time, though ye can leave me a message here if ye need to get ahold o’ me sooner.”
And so, up until he put out to sea, that was how it had gone. He had made sure to send extra before he went out and had been planning on sending enough for Spock to get his own place within a few more days, but now instead would be bringing himself.
Whatever that would ultimately mean.
“You look good,” McCoy said, after they stood on either side of the doorframe eying one another warily. He stepped aside and gestured Scotty in, then closed the door after he was.
"Aye, thanks," Scotty answered dismissively, looking around. Even without him there to take up space, even without his and Spock’s work, the place felt cramped and lousy.
There was no evidence of Kirk, either. So, either he had moved out or he was wise enough to be elsewhere right now.
Scotty was just about to round on McCoy and ask where Spock was when Nyota came out of the bathroom; despite every complicated, uncomfortable feeling being here brought him, the sound of joy she made on seeing him had him smiling.
They hadn't been close, but he'd done his best to watch out for her, and she had done the same; had been the one to send him out on errands more than a few times because she had noticed how oppressive being there was for him. They had spent part of the summer climbing out onto the roof at night, too, trying to shake off the awful heat of the day and maybe find space to breathe; he had listened to her stories about growing up, and to the tales of her lost family, and even occasionally shared one of his own, albeit only something from the Enterprise.
So it was an easy thing to hug her back when she wrapped her arms around him, and not-easy but welcomed when she reached up to touch his face, smiling brightly. "You look wonderful," she said, and then laughed when he took her hand and kissed the back of it gallantly.
"I tried to say somethin' like that and he blew me off like I was a cockroach sittin' on his shoulder," McCoy grumbled, though without any of the bite he was sometimes capable of.
"Simple answer, McCoy: She's a far sight prettier and I like her better," Scotty handed back, keeping the tone just light enough, though he did happen to mean it.
He didn't hate McCoy, but he didn’t forgive the man suggesting that Christmas was a perfect time for Kirk to propose to Edith, while he and Spock tried to figure out how to save all their futures and had to come to the devastating conclusion that they didn't have it in them.
Nyota knew it, too; her face softened and she gave his hand a squeeze before letting go, stepping in artfully and steering the line of conversation to something less like a minefield. "Some of your 'r's' have gone missing since the last time we talked, Mister."
"Ayuh, hazards o' bein' surrounded by Massholes." Scotty had not actually been aware of it, but he wasn't too surprised. He'd spent almost twenty years with his shore address in Maine, and inevitably sounded like it whenever he'd been ashore there long enough; he was never able to entirely shake off Aberdeen and defaulted back towards it when he was deployed, but he'd been in New England long enough this time that hazards had come out as hazahds just now.
All linguistics aside, though, he hadn’t come down for a casual get together. "How's Spock?" he asked, addressing them both.
McCoy nodded towards the bedroom he used to timeshare with Nyota. "In there. He hasn't eaten in three days, and the last time I tried to ask if he wanted help, he threw the bedside lamp at me."
Scotty’s eyebrows made for skyward at that; he looked back at Nyota for clarification, and she nodded. Then she took his hand again and gave him a tug towards the other side of the living room, lowering her voice to keep it between them. "Given my studies of the Vulcan language, I-- think I might know what's happening to him. I can't confirm that, Vulcans are very private about it, but-- I'm afraid for his life right now, Scotty."
Scotty had bent his head to listen, but that had him looking towards that door for a long moment, more unprepared than he might have expected for the jolt of fear he felt on Spock’s behalf at that. Then he looked back at Nyota, keeping his own voice similarly low. "Can ye tell me anything else, lass? Can we help him?"
"I-- shouldn't. That should be his to tell," she said, gently. "And I did offer to help, but he refused. Strained, but kindly. I don’t know if you'll have more luck talking with him, but I hope so."
"Aye. I can try, anyway." He offered her the best reassuring look he could drum up, then went over there and gave a light knock on the door. "Mister Spock?"
The answer wasn't immediate, but it came anyway, though it was hoarse-sounding when it did. "Come in."
That bedroom had the misfortune of catching the afternoon and evening sun. A kind thing in winter, but less so in summer. But even now, after dark, the heat and humidity still lingered and the single open window gave little relief, especially with the door closed, allowing no real airflow.
Scotty had persisted in finding a rental with central air, despite the moderating sea breeze in Fairhaven, because the last summer in this apartment had about killed him. At least after he was done baking all day, he could sleep cool at night.
He didn't comment on it, though, or the darkness. There was an overhead light, but he made no move to turn it on, just put half his ass on the window sill. "McCoy called me, told me ye were sick."
"In a manner of speaking," Spock answered. Sitting on the bed, he was little more than a shadow; one rough around the edges. His silhouette put Scotty in mind of the construction paper creations that Dan Howland's grandbabies decorated his refrigerator with. "I would not have called you. Did you miss work?"
"Only half an afternoon," Scotty said, resting his shoulder to the window frame. "Nothin' I'm worried for. And Miss Uhura seems to think yer life might be in danger, which is plenty enough reason for me to drive down. Is it?"
They had gotten very good, over the years, at being frank with one another. Even though Spock sometimes grew frustrated with Scotty’s more metaphorical language use, and even though Scotty sometimes had to remind himself that Spock’s nitpicking wasn't intended to cause hurt feelings, they were plenty capable of cutting through any bullshit.
If still both rather guarded by nature, even then.
"As things stand, yes," Spock answered, a more notable irritation coloring his voice. "It's not a sickness; not one as McCoy would understand it, despite its potential to be fatal. But I am a kind of-- unwell."
"Is it the kind of unwell that somethin' can be done about?" Scotty asked back, trying to grasp the problem enough to offer a solution.
"Nothing I'm willing to ask of anyone." Spock made a short motion in the dark; not an attack, maybe a gesture. His voice was sharp, though, as he said, "This is Vulcan business, engineer. Not yours."
The words were snappish enough to get Scotty to cross his arms, but even then, he knew better than to take it personally.
Spock must have realized how that had come across, though, and added, "Your help these past months has made my life considerably more bearable, Mister Scott. However, this is not something a more suitable diet and better clothing can fix."
"We reinvented duotronics with bloody-mindedness and parts out of a Tandy 3000, Mister Spock," Scotty pointed out, dryly. "I can't believe we'd fail to solve this, too."
There was a long stretch of quiet that fell there, though Scotty could all but sense the Vulcan chewing up real estate in his own mind, even half across the room. So, he just let it be quiet and rested his head against the heat cracked paint of the windowpane, closing his eyes, giving Spock the space to make some decisions.
It might have been twenty minutes before Spock spoke again, long enough that Scotty had half-dozed there, the heat making him feel lethargic now that he was sitting still long enough for it to work on him.
"I am-- betrothed," Spock said, pulling Scotty back to the room from whatever sweltering half-dream. "That's the closest human term for it; a marriage contract and a limited bond was formed between myself and my intended when we were children, so that when we reached the appropriate age and sexual maturity, we would be drawn together."
His voice was still rough, but where before it sounded lined with irritation, now it turned to something more like his familiar tones.
"Being only half-Vulcan, it was a possibility that I would never experience this-- mating drive," Spock said, tone shading into some manner of vague disgust briefly. "However-- now I have, and obviously I am unable to return to Vulcan to consummate the marriage bond."
Scotty didn’t know all that much about Vulcan, though his brother did, having spent two years studying there and still having at least one friend kept from that time. But he could guess pretty quickly why Spock sounded so-- unhappy about it. If it was a strong enough surge of feeling that it had him chucking lamps at McCoy, it would have to be distressing for a being whose self-control was central to his existence to lose it in that fashion.
"And-- ye'll get sicker because o' that?"
"Yes."
"And it has to be with yer betrothed."
"No."
Scotty’s eyebrow went up there, as he tried to sort all of the puzzle pieces out and form them into a picture he could understand. "Help me grasp this: ye need to consummate a bond, but the person ye're supposed to consummate it with won't be born for a couple centuries--"
"--the bond is only a direction for the drive to mate to point in," Spock said, snappish again, though not terribly much. "The drive would exist independent of the bond. But as my intended is not here, nor indeed any Vulcan, and I refuse to ask such a thing from anyone else, I am at the mercy of it."
That did a bit more to explain it. Scotty nodded along, letting the irritable tone roll off his back. "Aye, I'm gettin' it. But Nyota said that she offered to help ye. Is that-- not somethin' ye're willin' to do? Or would it not work with a human?"
"Her offer was kind, but not one I'm willing to take." Spock sounded a little like he was having to dumb things down, which Scotty figured-- fair enough, he was an engineer, not an expert on cultures. "It's possible with a human," Spock continued. "My mother is with my father when he is subsumed by the drive. But it will never leave either side unchanged. That's why Vulcans put those bonds into place, to hopefully direct us to a future spouse. There is nothing casual about pon farr. It often leads to a permanent, heightened awareness of another living person and a tendency towards a permanent relationship. The intimacy of it leaves no room for privacy. And beyond that, it's physically, mentally and emotionally taxing even for Vulcans, let alone what it would be for a human."
McCoy would probably have sniped at Spock about him having no emotions; Scotty wouldn't cheapen either of them by doing the same. Instead, he ticked over the dilemma at hand, pausing in his thoughts only to ask, plainly but gently, "Do ye want to continue living, Mister Spock? Ye'll get no judgment for me, mind, whatever yer answer."
Spock, of course, gave the question all of the time it probably needed, then said, "Sometimes, I don't believe that I do. But on the greater part-- yes. I have been seeking a way to find and contact the Vulcan observers I know are stationed here on Earth at this time. They may even have answers for our future that we don't. They may have a way to save our future. I can't do that if I'm dead."
Scotty knew better than to give into any glimmers of hope there himself. For him, every single day had to start with a question about whether he intended to see the end of it, and what it would take to accomplish that. But it touched him that Spock could still reach for that; this world wasn't an easy one to live in for any of them, but least of all for Spock.
So, Scotty let it tick over for awhile; when he spoke again, it was considered:
"I've thought often about those stanzas ye quoted me, last December. They might well have saved my life, too." He chewed on it for another moment, then went on, "There's another part that follows onto that, too, I've had to remind myself of since:
"'Fare forward.
"O voyagers, O seamen,
"You who came to port, and you whose bodies
"Will suffer the trial and judgment of the sea,
"Or whatever event, this is your real destination.'
"So Krishna, as when he admonished Arjuna
"On the field of battle.
"Not fare well,
"But fare forward, voyagers."
It was the continuing dialogue of an internal debate about the nature of change; of forward momentum. Scotty didn’t know that he understood it even now, but he thought he could grasp enough of it to appreciate the sentiment conveyed in 'not fare well, but fare forward.' There was more than one way to take 'fare well', there, too -- both in the terms of goodbye and literal wellness, and that ambiguity also appealed to him.
Both resonated with him, then and now: Spock’s desire to remember him unchanged, and his own willingness to acknowledge, for Spock, that life could not remain such, for as long as it lasted.
"Anyway-- you want to live. And ye need someone to go through this with ye." Scotty nodded, half to himself, half to Spock. "So," he asked, "how 'bout I do?"